In November, we achieved a 2.4% gain, more than recovering the loss experienced in October. This rebound coincided with a shift in the UK market, which had been oversold amidst negative sentiment. By month-end, the market appeared less oversold, sentiment had moderated, and, arguably, risks had increased. Consequently, we decided to re-hedge1 our positions at the close of the month.
Equity Markets: Extreme Valuations and Regional Disparities
Equity markets are exhibiting increasingly extreme characteristics, with regional disparities that are now striking. For some time, US equities have commanded higher valuations and shown faster earnings growth compared to Europe or the UK. However, the divergence has been exacerbated by factors such as the threat of Trump-era tariffs and political uncertainty in Europe.
In the US, post-election optimism has driven equity valuations and sentiment to historically dangerous levels. Extreme positioning, over-optimistic sentiment, and elevated valuations are evident across the board. Both institutional and retail investors appear to be “all in,” amplifying risks.
We have previously highlighted Professor Shiller’s cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings (CAPE) ratio. When adjusting the profit margin in this ratio to its long-term average, the valuation extremes become even starker. US equities are trading at a record-high adjusted valuation of 40x earnings—exceeding the peak of the year 2000. This adjustment is significant, as corporate profit margins, in a free-market system, are among the most reliably mean-reverting metrics in economics. Historical analysis of this series suggests strongly negative returns for US equities over the next decade.
While the current enthusiasm for US equities is understandable, it has rarely been accompanied by such elevated risks. Warren Buffett’s actions reinforce this caution—he is holding a record cash reserve of $300 billion, and his preferred valuation measure (market cap-to-GDP) is also at an all-time high. For US equities to return to their historical average valuation under this measure, they would need to decline by nearly 50%.
Europe: A Contrasting Story with Its Own Challenges
In stark contrast, European equities remain deeply undervalued relative to their US counterparts. Sentiment is poor, earnings growth has been subdued, and valuations are attractive. Yet, Europe faces significant challenges.
Recent purchasing manager data indicates that the European economy is contracting at an annualized rate of approximately 0.5% of GDP, even before considering the potential impact of US tariffs. It is likely that both the Eurozone and UK economies are already in recession.
On the political front, Europe is grappling with considerable instability. The French government appears vulnerable, and upcoming elections in Germany early next year could further unsettle markets. Economic growth is stagnant, debt levels are alarmingly high, and budget deficits remain unsustainably large. Compounding these issues is a lack of public appetite for the austerity measures necessary to stabilize the situation, particularly as many Europeans feel they have not significantly benefited from the recent economic cycle.
Although European equities present compelling value, the risk of a disruptive market event stemming from political instability or debt sustainability concerns looms large. Such an event would likely affect not only European markets but also the UK.
Risks of a Global Trade War
A further escalation in trade tensions, such as the imposition of new US tariffs on Europe and China, could deepen economic challenges. Markets seem to have discounted the potential for retaliation from Europe and China, which could rebound negatively on the US economy. This risk is particularly concerning given that US equities are currently priced for perfection, leaving little margin for error.
Navigating the Risks
While our recent hedging decisions may seem overly cautious in hindsight, the multitude of risks in the current environment leads us to prioritize capital preservation. As the legendary investor Nathan Rothschild once said:
“I never invest at the bottom and always sell too soon.”
This prudent approach underpinned his enormous success and serves as a guiding principle for us in these uncertain times.
Thank you for your continued support.
1 From time to time, the fund uses FTSE 100 equity futures to protect the value of the fund. When the hedge is applied, net equity exposure is reduced, and the capital should be largely protected.


