Tariffs

Delusion Is Not a One-Party Issue

In the run-up to the US presidential election, Republican voices had plenty to say about the Democrats’ apparent detachment from reality—particularly on cultural and social issues. But while it’s easy to laugh at others’ illusions, magical thinking is not the preserve of the political left. MAGA has its own version, and it’s arguably more dangerous—because this time, the delusion is economic.

At the heart of it is the idea that the United States can use tariffs to unwind globalisation, revive domestic manufacturing, and somehow turn the clock back to a 1950s-style industrial economy. It’s a romantic vision—but unfortunately, it’s not grounded in the realities of today’s world.

Post-WWII, the US had a unique advantage: it was the only major economy left standing. Europe and Japan were in ruins, and China barely registered as a player in global manufacturing. Fast forward to today, and the picture is entirely different. China is now the world’s dominant manufacturing power. According to a KPMG report from 2020, labour costs in US manufacturing are roughly 2.5 times higher than in China. While the US may have some efficiency advantages, they are unlikely to make up that gap. To truly rebalance this disparity, tariffs would have to be both large and permanent.

But tariffs come with significant costs—and deep uncertainty. Take, for example, the auto industry. Building a new car plant takes around five years and between $500 million and $1 billion, depending on size. Any multinational thinking about shifting production to the US must weigh that against the risk that a different administration could reverse course before the factory even opens its doors.

Despite the headlines, real investment is likely to lag. Corporations may issue pro-Trump statements, but behind the scenes, they will wait. The more probable outcome is that American consumers simply end up paying more for goods, while global manufacturers sit on their hands to see who’s in the White House in 2029.

There’s also a fiscal twist. President Trump has floated the idea that tariff revenues could fund tax cuts. If this happens, the result is effectively a transfer from lower-income households (who spend a higher share of their income on goods) to wealthier individuals (who benefit disproportionately from tax cuts and are less affected by rising prices).

So, far from returning to the more equal, middle-class America of the 1950s, we may be headed for the opposite: wider inequality, stubborn inflation, and weaker growth. Tariffs are taxes. And no country has ever taxed its way to prosperity.

This is a policy born from nostalgia rather than strategy. The risk is not revival—but recession. And not just any recession, but one marked by stagflation—a toxic mix of inflation and stagnation. If there is a boom coming, it is more likely to be in wishful thinking than in real investment.

Menu